TWR: C19 Spoilers – The Populate Deck

Wednesday was the reveal of the populate-themed Primal Genesis deck. Outside of the commander and a couple of cards that were included in all decks, we didn’t know much about this one outside of its theme. Keeping with the pattern that I’ve noticed, this was the deck they were building up to, or at least this is the deck that has appealed to me the most out of the three that have now been spoiled. Naya isn’t exactly my favorite color combination (that distinction belongs to Esper currently), but it works fine for my dinosaur tribal deck. Since the main theme of the deck is to create tokens and then populate to create more tokens, it seems my initial assessment that it would be hard to go wide was unfounded. It seems that WotC saw the same issue that I did and baked in plenty of support. Anyway, let’s get on with the reveal!

Alternate Commanders:

I really like Alta Palani, but not for the same reason that other people do. Many are building him as egg tribal, and though there is a good selection of cards from the game’s history that are eggs or egg related, I just don’t see that as being a fun idea. However, in my dinosaur deck, this is just another way besides using Gishath to cheat big creatures onto the battlefield, and for that I want this card. I’m actually into Marisi as well, but for different reasons. It’s nice to be able to stop opponents from casting spells on your turn, but it’s also nice to be able to goad them into attacking other players. I feel like this one belongs in a control deck, or perhaps a Najeela warrior deck, but I actually don’t see a home for it just yet, will still be happy to try and find one though. The final two color general is only so-so. It’s one of those weird switcharoo cards and I just don’t have the energy to try and brew around those. Your mileage may vary.

New Cards:

There are a few interesting new cards here. Some I did not share due to being in other decks and having already talked about them. Out of these I like the Commander’s Insignia — especially for low costed commanders that might be played 3-5 times in a game, that’s quite a boon. Song of the Worldsoul is a nice populate trigger, Full Flowering can be huge given the mana, and the Eulogist is a nice piece of graveyard hate along with populating at the same time. Idol of Oblivion is nice card draw if you’re always populating, but it can be sacrificed to make a 10/10, and that’s not bad! Honestly these are all pretty good, though they’re mostly good in this deck. Whatever the case I intend on picking this one up for sure!

Notable Reprints:

Only a few notables here, though there are a ton of reprints that are just fine for the deck. Feldon and Trostani are both older legendaries that fit into a ton of decks, so they are definitely ones you’ll want in you collection. I have a copy of the former already, but I don’t doubt I’ll be able to find a spot for another. This version of Garruk may not be the most powerful, but it’s a classic Planeswalker and I like it for that fact. I also don’t own a copy so bonus! Lastly, the Sakura Tribe Elder is basically an EDH staple and I have a few copies but more never hurt. As I said, out of the three decks this one has appealed to me the most and it’s highest on my list to pick up come the end of the month. I have my doubts that the Madness deck will be any better than this, but I’ll check in tomorrow to talk about those cards as well. Then we can get back to talking about other stuff, my apologies to those of you who aren’t MTG fans, but this is hype season for the game and more specifically this format and I couldn’t pass up the opportunity to talk about them.

TWR: C19 Spoilers – The Flashback Deck

On Tuesday, the next Commander 2019 deck was revealed, and this time we’re looking at Mystic Intellect – The Jeskai Flashback theme. Once again, a video was released by The Command Zone, and the deck list was released on the mothership. This time only one card seem to be missing from the list, and I think this may have something to do with exclusive reveals reserved for someone in particular. Whatever the case, I won’t be able to share Bloodthirsty Blade with you due to its non-inclusion. This deck was one that I thought I might actually want due to having brewed a few spellslinging decks in these colors recently and still needing some of the cards. I like buying the precons and playing with them a few times before breaking them down into parts. Some of the lands, artifacts and other EDH staples are great to get in chunks like this as well. Some cards won’t ever see play, but that’s the price of doing business in a CCG. Anyhow, let’s get on with the show.

Alternate Commanders:

This is the first time I can recall where the alternate commanders included in the deck aren’t all really suited for leading the precon. Clearly, Elsha of the Infinite is a damn fine card, and honestly is a card that I would use as the commander, putting Sevinne in the 99, but I also see it as being the legendary in the deck to build around. Pramikon is interesting in that it’s the first legendary wall in the game, and people are freaking out about building wall tribal with it. However it doesn’t do anything for walls unlike Arcades or even Doran, so I don’t see the point. In some weird control deck this might fit, otherwise I’m thinking it’s pretty underwhelming. Gerrard also doesn’t feel like it belongs in this deck, but I think he’ll find a spot in some Boros deck at some point. Whatever the case, there’s one alternate here that feels at home and two that feel shoehorned in.

New Cards:

There are several cards here I really like, and already see a place for in existing decks. Backdraft Hellkite would slot into Kaalia nicely as an upgrade to some other dragon and some recursion for spells. Dockside Extortionist is possibly my favorite card from this deck. I love playing mono-red Goblins with Krenko at the helm, and it’s constantly changing because new awesome Goblins keep appearing in each new set. This one is a doozy, giving you a huge amount of ramp for a turn particularly if you cast him later in the game when everyone has at least a couple of mana rocks and maybe an enchantment. I look forward to abusing this one. I’m also rather excited about Wall of Stolen Identity as well, for my Arcades wall deck. Copying a creature is something the deck couldn’t do before, and it’s also temporary removal of said creature so bonus. Otherwise these other cards are fine, just not as exciting.

Notable Reprints:

Sun Titan and Clever Impersonator are just good cards in their colors and though they have been printed a couple of times already, they always creep up in price. The original Ral Zerek was getting up there too, and is a good Planeswalker to add to the collection. That ultimate can net you crazy extra turns and that’s nothing to sneeze at! Lastly, Jace’s Sanctum is a fairly underused but awesome enchantment for spells matter decks. The mana reduction on spells is nice, being able to scry each time you cast a spell is nice too, allowing you to filter through cards that aren’t going to help your current situation, or to set up better for Elsha! It’s good in any blue deck that wants to manipulate the top of their library.

Overall this deck is getting warmer. The first deck didn’t speak to me, but I’m seeing some good stuff in this one. If this pattern continues, I’ll really like today’s deck. I’ll check in with you guys tomorrow once I know more.

TWR: C19 Spoilers – The Morph Deck

As promised, the Command Zone released a video talking about one of the four new Commander 2019 decks, and Wizards of the Coast revealed the full deck list simultaneously on the Mothership. Follow that link to see the list, you can also watch the YouTube video of the Command Zone directly on that page. Feel free to do that and then you can come back for my commentary. Monday’s deck reveal was of “Faceless Menace,” the Sultai-colored Morph-themed deck. The only thing I’ve noticed is that there are a couple of cards that I can’t seem to find spoilers for although they are present in the deck list, so I cannot comment on those just yet. As themes go, this one heavily leans on the Morph mechanic, which looks to be very powerful and synergistic. However, the mechanic simply isn’t interesting to me as a playstyle, so I don’t think I’m going to pick this one up. Still, let’s take a look at the cards, you might find some of this more appealing than I do.

Alternate Commanders:

The alternate commander suite is very much on theme, but the only one that I think is remotely intriguing is Volrath. His ability to place counters on creatures to make them weaker and then simultaneously be able to copy that creature while remaining a 7/5 is pretty decent. I can see him being his own general and probably being pretty decent due to these colors. Rayami is probably a voltron commander at best. Someone in one of my MTG groups pointed out that Grismold goes very well with Night of Souls’ Betrayal – which is an enchantment that gives all creatures -1/-1 so that he’s getting +4/+4 at the end of each of your turns, but then he’s probably still going voltron and it’s not as if he doesn’t die to removal. So all around I think Kadena herself should remain the obvious choice for commander of this deck.

New Cards:

Each of these preconstructed decks contain a ton of reprints, so there are only a few brand-new-to-the-format cards. Those are pictured above, outside of the couple that I mentioned are not online yet for some reason (Mire in Misery and Voice of Many are the missing cards). I also did not include already spoiled cards, you can check those out in older The War Report posts. There are some things here, but the only card I’d really like to own is the Apex Altisaur, as it would slot into Gishath quite nicely. Road of Return is pretty good, particularly for expensive commanders. I don’t like Sudden Substitution, but I’m sure there’s some trickery to be had with it. The Gift of Doom aura is blah. Thieving Amalgam and Scroll of Fate are great for the morph theme but otherwise fairly useless. Lastly, the Pendant of Prosperity is great for group hug themes but probably not used much otherwise. So overall I’m not really into the new cards made for this deck, and I can safely say there aren’t even reprints I’m dying to have that are included, though some are good cards if you don’t already own them.

Notable Reprints:

I’m not going to go over all of the reprints because they are old news, but I will say that the above are good cards for your collection. Seedborn Muse if fantastic in basically any green deck, but better in those that will abuse it. Deathmist Raptor was one of the beast creature cards that was changed to a dinosaur once the tribe became recognized during the Ixalan block. This is the first reprinting of the card with the new creature subtype. Strionic Resonator is a great card for commanders with triggered abilities, while Thespian’s Stage is a land that combos with several other lands to do fun things. Lastly, Vraska the Unseen is one of my favorite versions of the Planeswalker, though it wasn’t exactly expensive prior to this. Still, these are a nice pick up and if you really enjoy the mechanics in this deck I think it’s going to perform pretty well against the other decks and we haven’t even seen those yet.

The Flashback-themed deck is being revealed in a few minutes. I’ll be back tomorrow with thoughts on that.

TWR: Commander 2019 Spoilers: Round Two

While Gen Con has been finishing up, there were two more panels featuring spoilers from the upcoming Commander 2019 decks. The initial spoilers from a couple of days ago were just the commanders and their accompanying signature cards, and we got even fewer spoilers from there on. However, we are supposed to see a complete deck list for one of the four decks each day from Monday through Thursday next week, so then we’ll really be able to judge the value coming down the pipeline. On Friday, one new legendary creature, a spell and a land were revealed:

This new legendary is pretty nuts. He’s expensive, but only if you pay the full 7 CMC. He has phyrexian mana in his CMC, which we haven’t seen for a while, and is also quite powerful. This means that one can pay either three black mana or six life plust the four generic mana to cast this creature, and that opens up a bunch of options. Not only that, but he also effectively turns all black mana symbols in phyrexian mana which can really help to break black. It doesn’t stop there though, K’rrik also gets +1/+1 for each black spell you cast, and he has lifelink to heal you back up after spending life as a resource. There are some aristocrats, some extort creatures and other lifelinkers to make this into a viable way to cheat a bunch of cards out. I’m looking forward to brewing around this one. Next up, a spell and a land that sort of do the same thing in different ways. The spell is a little more flexible, as it can remove an opponent’s commander and also replaces itself with a card. The land would be more focused on returning your own commander to your hand, but it can only be done during your turn, so it’s likely just an extra blink effect for those commanders who want that. I don’t really find either of these cards very appealing. On Saturday there was another new legendary and one new creature spoiled:

Gerrard is fine I guess. A 4 CMC 3/3 with first strike is very Boros. He plays well with board wipes, particularly those that target both creatures and artifacts, as he will return all of those permanents back to the battlefield afterwards. Seems pretty niche, and not something worth building around. Probably pretty good in a deck that’s wiping often. As for the new creature, the Scaretiller is decent but a little expensive. It will ramp you each time it’s tapped, so this is probably baller in affinity decks that are always tapping and untapping artifacts. Probably good in Windgrace as well, to constantly return lands from the yard to feed your Gitrog Monster.

Overall, I have not been overly thrilled with any of the spoilers so far. I like K’rrik, but I’m not in love. We’ll check back in later this week with more on this set.

TWR: Commander 2019 Spoilers: The Face Cards

As of August 1st, spoiler season for the new Commander 2019 preconstructed decks has begun. Gen Con is going on, and Wizards is there — information was promised at a panel yesterday, and supposedly there will be more information given today as well. Next week we’ll get the full deck lists one at a time for four days. My plan as I laid out in yesterday’s post, is to report on the new information each day we get it, so today’s post focuses on what we learned yesterday, and I’ll have more to report after the panel later this afternoon (probably tomorrow’s post). That also means next week I’ll have four posts about the individual deck lists as well. With that said, let’s dig into yesterday’s reveals:

So far, we’ve been shown the box art, names of each deck and the face cards. Each of these new commanders has its own signature spell or companion creature similar to the cycle from last year’s product (you’ll know by the name of the card). So we have the Sultai Faceless Menace deck led by Kadena, Jeskai Mystic Intellect featuring Sevinne, Naya Primal Genesis with Ghired at the helm, and finally the Rakdos Merciless Rage deck sporting Anje. Firstly, I’m surprised by the fact that there are three 3-color decks and one that is only two, but I guess it makes sense given these keywords’ prevalence in those colors. Anyway, let’s take a closer look at the new generals:

Kadena, Slinking Sorcerer is a four CMC 3/3, which isn’t too impressive on its own. This is the commander of the morph keyword deck, so of course its other text has to do with the morph mechanic. The first creature you cast face down (via morph) each turn costs 3 less to cast, meaning you can cast that one for free, as the morph rules texts reads that you can cast this creature face down for 3. One free creature per turn isn’t terrible, and then those cards can be flipped in order to abuse other mechanics or surprise with an attacker or blocker. It’s an interesting enough mechanic, but it’s also one that I’ve never really cared much about. It is nice to get that free cast though, and as a bonus you get to draw a card for any morph creatures you play. I can see this being a pretty reliable card draw engine, but I don’t seem morph being a mechanic that will win you games.

The flashback keyword commander, Sevinne, the Chronoclasm is a five CMC 2/2… and that’s just bad. It is essentially indestructible which is nice, and it’s other rules text is only so-so. Basically anytime you cast one of your flashback spells from the graveyard you get to copy it. So there are a ton of copy spell effects in these colors, so I’m sure this can be a pretty decent storm deck given a good amount of mana, but it’s still pretty boring. I’m hoping there are some good cards in the deck otherwise, because this was the deck I was banking on being the one that I would buy first.

Ghired, Conclave Exile is our populate keyword commander. A five CMC 2/5, his stats are okay for the cost, but he does have an ETB effect that gives you a 4/4 with trample so you are actually getting 6/9 on the board for five, so that’s not terrible. As a bonus, if you can give him haste,  you can immediately attack and populate (make a copy of a creature token you control) giving you another 4/4 that’s tapped and attacking. Haste will make this a more aggressive deck, and you actually have access to green so ramping into him isn’t terrible. I have too many decks brewed already that utilize token strategies, but this one is probably the most interesting commander so far. If you’re making other big tokens, you can continue to make more of them each combat, but it’s pretty slow at going wide. I’m curious to see what else is in the box.

So Rakdos is kind of bad in my mind. I didn’t really like the madness mechanic back when it was in standard (and I was still playing standard back then). The thought of always discarding cards doesn’t feel like card advantage to me, but I guess that’s the point of madness, because madness cards typically cost less when they are discarded than if you cast them from hand, so in that way this commander fits the them well. Anje Falkenrath is a 1/3 for three CMC that comes with Haste. You can tap her to loot (discard and draw), but when you discard a card,  you can untap her. This can be broken. If they make the appropriate amount of good madness cards (as I remember it, there weren’t too many good ones in the past) this might be one of the best commanders of the bunch.

Overall I’m not really that interested in any of these face cards, and I remember sort of feeling that way last year as well. However, I do remember last year having some awesome alternate commanders though, so I’m banking on some awesome cards still appearing in these decks. Let’s take a look at the other spoilers we’ve had so far (by the way, Seedborn Muse was reprinted as well):

Nothing too exciting here either, though each plays well with its commander, so they make sense to be named after them. Here’s hoping for some new cycles, some good reprints and some alternate commanders that are better than these face cards! We’ll touch base as more information becomes available.